MOUSE MENU

OCTOBER 2025

Stop in or call us to place an order: (914) 579-2909

Please note: Prices do not include NYS Sales or Local Sales Tax

SANDWICHES*

Bennington: Shelburne 2 Year Cheddar, Roasted Parsnips, Cider Onion Chutney & Arugula on Baguette $14

add Roasted Turkey + $3

Quincy: Local Baked Apple Chevre, Sliced Green Apple, Chipotle Maple Jam, and Arugula on Baguette $13

add Smoked Ham $3

Lucerne: Swiss Emmenthaler, Roasted Brussels Sprouts, Shallot Red Wine Confit $13

add Beef Saucisson Sec $4

GRILLED SANDWICHES*

Old School: Sharp American Cheese, served with a side of sweet pickles and our house-blend mustard. $13

Add Bacon for $2 or Tomato for $1

The New Classic: Our blend of Cheddar, Alpine and Pecorino Toscano, Garlic Aioli, house blend Mustard on Ciabatta or Gluten-Free Bread, served with a side of Tomato Jam or Bacon Marmalade $13

Hipster Grilled Cheese: Havarti melted atop Roasted Poblano Peppers, Green Salsa and Arugula on Ciabatta or local Gluten-Free bread $13

French Onion: Emmenthal and Comte, Rosemary French Onion Jam, Arugula on Ciabatta or local Gluten-Free Bread $13

Add Beef Saucisson Sec $3

Sweet & Salty Grilled Cheese: Caramelized Norwegian Cheese with Crispy Green Apple on Ciabatta or local Gluten-Free bread $12

*Sorry, we do not make custom sandwiches

SOUPS & OTHER COMFORT FOOD

Seasonal Special Soup: Butternut Squash! : Roasted Butternut Squash and Pear, Pureed with Vegetable Stock. Served with Stilton and Crumbled Walnuts (vegetarian, gf) $7 (Mini, 8oz); $12 (Small, 16oz); $24 (Large, 32oz)

Tomato Soup (vegetarian, gluten-free): Italian Tomatoes, a bit of smoke, Za’atar (contains sesame) and Creme Fraiche $5 (Mini, 8oz); $9 (Small, 16oz); $18 (Large, 32oz)

Lentil Soup (vegetarian, gluten-free): Lentils, Cremini Mushrooms, Organic Mushroom Broth, a hint of heat and Grana Padano. Served with a side of Creme Fraiche $5 (Mini, 8oz); $9 (Small, 16oz); $18 (Large, 32oz)

Shells ‘n’ Cheese (vegetarian): Organic Pasta, our blend of NYS Cheddar and Alpine Cheeses, a teeny tiny bit of Cauliflower, and a Breadcrumb Crust $9

CHEESE PLATES

Served with baguette, jam or honey, and dried fruit

Serving 1: $19; Serving 2: $24; Add Charcuterie $6pp

Choose 3 cheeses from below:

  • Capricho de Cabra (herbed goat cheese, Spain)

  • Nancy’s Camembert (rich cow/sheep triple creme, NY)

  • Reading Raclette (mildly stinky raw cow milk cheese, VT)

  • Ossau Iraty (firm sheep tomme, Spain)

  • Prairie Breeze Cheddar (sweet, crystalline cow cheddar, IA)

  • Point Reyes Original (creamy blue, raw cow, CA)

TODAY’S BREADS

Balthazar (NYC): Baguette $6 (Tues-Sat)

Amy’s (NYC): Semolina Raisin Fennel Bread $11; Olive Bread $11 (all week)

Wave Hill (CT): Sourdough Miche Quarter $10; Roman Focaccia $10; Cranberry Walnut Demi Baguettes $8 (Saturdays)

SWEETS

Second Mouse Panna Cotta: $7

New Castle Scone Co (Chappaqua): Traditional or Black Currant 3/$10; Samplers 2/$7; or 6/$17 (Weekends Only)

Balthazar (NY): Oat Currant Scones 2/$9 (Fridays & Saturdays)

Second Mouse Sour Cream Pecan Coffee Cake $7

Wave Hill (CT): Chocolate Chip Cookies $4.5